sellerguy

Sep 11 · 6 Answers

#Walmart

Walmart Marketplace – what's actually good and what's still broken?

I’ve been eyeing Walmart Marketplace as a potential expansion channel. I know it’s blown up since it launched, but I’m trying to get a real sense of where it’s at right now.

From what I’ve seen in old threads and random sources:

The good:

Lower competition than Amazon in many categories

Potentially better margins due to less aggressive price wars

WFS (Walmart Fulfillment) has matured significantly

Customers trust the Walmart brand

The bad:

Overall traffic is still much smaller than Amazon

Ad data reportedly lags (24-48 hours behind)

Return policy is very customer-friendly (costly for sellers)

Account suspension risks are real if metrics slip

Analytics tools are still behind Amazon

Also, some sellers report that Walmart’s ad algorithm is getting better, but it’s still not as intuitive as Amazon’s Sponsored Products

But most of these takes are from old threads. I’d love to hear from folks who are actually selling on Walmart right now:

Is competition noticeably increasing, or is there still room?

Has WFS improved profitability, or just added another fee?

What's the single biggest problem you face on Walmart today?

Would you recommend a new seller start with Walmart now?

I’m not here for promo fluff – just honest, real-world vibes from actual sellers.

Thanks a ton in advance.

Answers (6)

Damon Shaw Sep 16

I actually disagree with the "don't start now" vibe. Yeah competition's up, but compared to Amazon? Walmart's still a baby. The real play is off-Amazon traffic. I run Facebook ads to my Walmart listings – same audience, CPC is like $0.40 vs $1.20 on Amazon. And Walmart's organic ranking algorithm seems to love external traffic. I had one product that didn't rank at all for 3 months. Sent 200 clicks from FB and it jumped to page 2. Try that on Amazon – you'd get nothing. So if you're just gonna list and pray, don't bother. But if you're willing to drive your own traffic, Walmart's still a goldmine.

Tyler McIntyre

Sep 21

This is the first take on Walmart that actually makes sense to me. The external traffic part is what a lot of people skip over when they compare it to Amazon. Page 2 after 200 FB clicks is pretty telling, especially if the product had been stuck for months before that.

Patrick Archer

Sep 21

yeah, the Amazon comparison is doing a lot of work here

Ace Contreras

Sep 22

How are you measuring whether the Facebook traffic is actually converting on Walmart, though? I get the ranking bump part, but if CPC is cheap and the traffic doesnt buy, it feels like you could burn money pretty fast.

Warren Y. Russell

Sep 23

Depends on the product imo, but the traffic angle is interesting

Caitlin Fleming Sep 14

Biggest problem nobody talks about: inventory sync. I run both Amazon and Walmart off the same 3PL. Walmart's API glitches constantly. Last month they oversold my best SKU by 40 units because their system didn't pull inventory updates for like 36 hours. I opened a case – took them 8 days to respond. Eight. Days. Amazon would've fixed it in 2 hours. WFS helps a little, but then you're splitting inventory across two systems and losing flexibility. Anyone else dealing with this crap?

Angel Armstrong

Sep 20

Yeah, inventory sync is the part that gets ignored until it blows up. I had a similar issue with a different channel and the lag made the stock look fine when it was already basically gone. An 8 day response is wild though, that would make me nervous enough to keep a lot more buffer on hand just to avoid the oversell mess.

branddaily Sep 11

I've been on Walmart for a while. Here's my honest take:
The good: Margins are still better than Amazon in my categories (home goods). Less race-to-the-bottom pricing. WFS has been solid – once you're in, the 2-day badge helps conversion.
The bad: Data tools are a joke compared to Amazon. You're flying blind half the time. Ad reporting lags, so you can't optimize daily. Returns hurt – budget 5-8%.
Verdict: Worth it as a supplemental channel. Don't quit Amazon for it, but add it if you can. I still make most of my money on Amazon, but Walmart’s a nice little side hustle.

Alec Nixon

Sep 14

That lines up with what I’ve heard too. The margin part is the main reason I keep thinking about Walmart, but the data side always gives me pause. Flying blind with ad reporting lag sounds brutal if you’re used to Amazon Seller Central. When you say WFS has been solid, did you see a real bump once the 2-day badge kicked in, or was it more of a slow improvement over time?

brandbuddy Sep 13

Gotta disagree on the "ad algorithm is getting better" part. It's still trash. I dropped $2k last month and the search term report showed like 30% of my clicks were from totally irrelevant keywords. And you can't even negative target. Just gotta eat the waste. On Amazon I can dial in a campaign in a week. On Walmart? I'm still guessing after 6 months. The data lag is insane too – I'll see a sales spike on Tuesday but the ad report doesn't tell me why until Thursday. How the hell are you supposed to optimize a ghost?

Anthony Fleming Sep 12

Biggest problem nobody talks about: support is terrible. I swear, their support is the worst I’ve seen in any platform. Open a case, wait 3-5 days for a generic copy-paste response, then more days to actually solve anything. If something breaks, you're stuck.
Also, the "account suspension" fear is real. Keep your ODR under 2% and VTR above 99% religiously. They don't give warnings like Amazon – they just suspend.
One more thing: WFS is almost mandatory now. FBM still works in a few niches, but without the 2-day badge, you're leaving a lot on the table.

Walmart Marketplace – what's actually good and what's still broken?

Answers (6)

What is your community topic tag?

You created a new community!

What to do next

We use Cookies

Cookie Preferences

Necessary Cookies

Functional Cookies

Analytics Cookies

Marketing Cookies